Skip to Main Content

The United Kingdom's Statutory Bill of Rights: Constitutional and Comparative Perspectives

Online ISBN:
9780191760426
Print ISBN:
9780197265376
Publisher:
British Academy
Book

The United Kingdom's Statutory Bill of Rights: Constitutional and Comparative Perspectives

Roger Masterman (ed.),
Roger Masterman
(ed.)
Durham University
Find on
Ian Leigh (ed.)
Ian Leigh
(ed.)
Durham University
Find on
Published:
4 April 2013
Online ISBN:
9780191760426
Print ISBN:
9780197265376
Publisher:
British Academy

Abstract

More than a decade after it came into force in October 2000 the Human Rights Act 1998 continues to divide opinion. Its supporters argue that the Act represents a subtle reconciliation of human rights protection with the UK's parliamentary democratic tradition and that it has given rise to a sophisticated interplay between the judiciary and elected politicians. Critics of the Act, on the other hand, charge it with failing in one of two opposing directions — either by ushering in judicial supremacism or as an exercise in futility. Unloved by the political elite, the Act's future is once again under review. This book takes stock of the impact of the Human Rights Act. The relationship of the UK courts with the European Court of Human Rights in Strasbourg is examined as is the corresponding question of the status of Convention jurisprudence within domestic courts. The effect of the Act on democratic governance is assessed by chapters addressing the issues of dialogue and the impact of the Act on established constitutional principle. From a practitioner viewpoint the revolutionary impact on legal argument and reasoning is analysed. A comparison of the Westminster model with other schemes for rights protection adopted in New Zealand, Hong Kong, and some Australian states is undertaken to measure the international impact of the Human Rights Act. Finally, the question of further constitutional reform is discussed in chapters giving a Scottish perspective, examining the processes of enacting rights protections and on options for the ‘British Bill of Rights’.

Contents
Close
This Feature Is Available To Subscribers Only

Sign In or Create an Account

Close

This PDF is available to Subscribers Only

View Article Abstract & Purchase Options

For full access to this pdf, sign in to an existing account, or purchase an annual subscription.

Close